Jephthah’s daughter, fate of

For more than one hundred years this question has been before the Brotherhood: Did Jephthah actually sacrifice his only daughter, or did here merely dedicate her to a celibate service, perhaps at the Tabernacle? The earliest discussion of the subject of which I am aware occurs in the 1875 Christadelphian, in a brief article by JJ Andrew (Vol 12, May, pp 236,237). It is a measure of the “popularity” of this debate that there are no less than 32 separate articles — and these in the Christadelphian and Testimony magazines along — over the intervening 105 years. A fuller index of other periodicals would surely increase this number considerably. (One is tempted to inquire if a like number of words have been written on many other subjects of far more importance).

There has never been a Christadelphian “party line” on the question. In such respects as this our community compares very favorably with others, such as “Jehovah’s Witnesses” — who make a great show of devotion to individual Bible study, but who scarcely, if ever, deviate from the official interpretation of “headquarters” on any subject? A review of our writings on Jephthah’s vow, just as one minor example, reveals a great stress on private, personal, independent thinking along Scriptural lines. Surely it is a small price to pay for our community’s freedom from “learning by rote” that, once in a while, a question of secondary importance is allowed to overlap the bounds of “cut-and-dried”, canned (or “potted” — for the English) reasoning.

Robert Roberts is first on one side, then the other, of this subject. [His last thought on the subject favors the death of Jephthah’s daughter (Law of Moses, 1984 edition, pp 290,291) — but his argument is very brief and far from air-tight.] And CC Walker follows him in the same course — first favoring a dedication and then vacillating between the two and finally expressing “no doubt that Jephthah’s daughter was really slain in sacrifice” [Xd 64 (Jan 1927), p 28]. But his defense of that view seems curiously flippant, as, for example, his question: “What is a daughter more or less?” (Ibid, Feb, p 77) — certainly not designed to win the sisters over to his view, to say the least! Then, “making all due allowances”, as he expresses it, he reproduces a portion of a Tennyson poem which catches the “spirit of the maiden” — in which the poet sees her coming in a vision and then returning “toward the morning star”! (Ibid, p 86). Not much “proof” in that, certainly!

The next editor of the magazine, John Carter, weighs in on the other side of the issue, with an article by G. Buckler to the effect that the girl’s life was not taken — to which he appends his own note of approval [Xd, Vol 78 (June 1941), pp 260,261].

The Testimony Magazine also presents, at different times, both views. PH Adams, for years the editor of “First Stages” and then the “Problems” sections, has a real “problem” with this question! Issue after issue, he advances and repeats arguments for sacrifice instead of devotion — but his readers (if one may judge by the printed response) are overwhelmingly of the other school of thought. So, patiently and with good humor, he answers as best he can their objections. Reading these exchanges (In Volumes 11, 12, 13, 22, 23, and 27) is certainly a good lesson in the fine art of “disagreeing without being disagreeable”, something most of us could do with more of!

One of the most curious contributions on the subject is a “Trial in the Court of Historical Research” — before “Lord Penetrating Impartiality” (in the style of Robert Roberts’ “The Trial: Did Christ Rise from the Dead?”). Both sides of the question are argued out at length by counsels with such names as “Noble Acceptor-of-all-Truth”, after which the reader is left to decide for himself (Testimony, Vol 28 (April, 1958), pp 121-127).

What are the arguments, pro and con? The following is a summary of the more cogent points in favor of each side, for the benefit of those who do not have access to back numbers of our periodicals:

First, in favor of the theory that Jephthah did indeed offer his daughter as a burnt offering:

  1. We cannot say that anything God does or allows is inconsistent with His declared character. It is not for us to sit in judgment of Him.

  2. This view was never called in question by Jew or Christian until about 1200 AD. The Septuagint and Vulgate — and Josephus — have always conveyed the idea of a literal sacrifice.

  3. Just because Jephthah is elsewhere described as a righteous man does not mean everything he did was righteous! To believe that he offered up his daughter does not require believing that he was right in doing so!

  4. The AV text (if not the margin), RV, RSV, and most other versions favor the “and” in v 31 — giving strong support to the idea that the vow called for the burnt offering of whatever or whoever came out first, since (no matter how we understand its terms) it is beyond any doubt that Jephthah did perform his vow (v 39).

  5. Would Jephthah’s sorrow have been so overwhelming, and would an annual memorial have been called for, if the only “fate” his daughter suffered was perpetual virginity and service at the Tabernacle?

And, secondly, for the alternate theory:

  1. Human sacrifice was expressly forbidden by God (Deu 12:30,31; Psalm 106:37,38; Isa 66:3; Jer 32:34,35).

  2. Jephthah, being one who “wrought righteousness” and “obtained a good report through faith” (Heb 11:32,33-39), can hardly be expected to have been so seriously ignorant of what was and was not acceptable to God in this matter. It is very improbable that a man like that would make a vow that would likely call for him to do something which the Law expressly forbade.

  3. The “vow” Jephthah made (Jdg 11:30) was a “nadar” — for which the Law allowed the possibility of redemption upon payment of money. (Lev 27:1,8). Considering this, it is almost unthinkable that the distraught father would not have availed himself of this “escape” if the vow had meant death for his daughter. (The Hebrew for “devoted” things, which could not be redeemed, was “cherem”, as in Lev 27:29, but that word does not appear in this narrative.

  4. “Whatsoever” of v 31 can be translated “whosoever”, as applying to persons. This is a reference, probably, to the custom of women coming out to meet victorious warriors, with timbrels and dancing (v 34). The women who met David returning from battle (1Sa 18:6) and Miriam also (Exo 15:20) were following this custom. It seems very unlikely that Jephthah would have been vowing to put to death “whomsoever” of the young men or women came out first, as he would surely have realized beforehand how likely it would have been for a human rather than an animal to come out first!

  5. “I will offer it up” (v 31) can be translated “I will offer Him (ie, God) a burnt offering” — making the pronoun masculine, with God the One to whom the offering was to be made.

  6. “And I will offer it up”: The AV margin suggests “or” (though the preponderance of translations favors “and”), so that Jephthah may be expressing an alternative; ie, If a person comes out first, he or she shall be dedicated to God, or if an animal comes out first (and if it possesses the suitable qualities) it will be sacrificed as a burnt offering.

  7. If there had been any illegality in the vow, that is, if in fact the outcome had been a human sacrifice, then someone like Jephthah — who feared God — would have had good reason to forbid the breaking of His law.

  8. The burnt offering of the damsel, if such it was, would have to be carried out be a priest at the Tabernacle — who would then be knowingly participating in an improper offering and a criminal act!

  9. Furthermore, the specific rules of the burnt offering (Lev 1:1-17,7:8) provided that a male be offered, the skin to belong to the priests, and the blood to be sprinkled round the altar!

  10. In lamenting her misfortune, Jephthah’s daughter did not bewail the loss of life; she simply bewailed her “virginity”. This deprivation of the opportunity to bear children was considered a great calamity among Jews, and would be especially hard to bear for Jephthah also — since he was an important man in Israel and she was an only child. The word “lament” (Hebrew “lethanoth”) in v 40 is not the common word for such, which would have been most appropriate if the grief of death were intended. Instead, it is a word which can have the meaning “to rehearse” or “to talk with” — as the margin shows. It is used only here and in Judges 5:11, where the daughters of Israel retell and celebrate the righteous acts of God. The young women evidently went up to the Tabernacle to talk with Jephthah’s daughter year by year.

  11. “She knew no man” (v 39) seems foolishly redundant if she were put to death. It rather seems to express her entering upon a state of complete dedication to Yahweh — in some special service. (Compare Hannah offering Samuel during the same period). Though similar to Roman Catholic nuns and “holy orders”, such a dedication should not be objected to on that score alone, since this would be a dedication in truth, not error. Paul says that the unmarried may more easily care for the things of God (1Co 7:34). Such an order of virgins devoted to Tabernacle and Temple service is at least implied in such passages as Lam 1:4 and Exo 38:8.

  12. It is not explicitly stated that she was actually offered — which is rather remarkable in so singular a case. This seems so unusual an omission that even the commentators who favor the idea of sacrifice are compelled to admit that a “veil” is drawn over the actual bloodshedding. But is it not more reasonable to assume that there was nothing in the narrative so embarrassing to Jephthah’s character that a veil was even needed?

***

A quick reading of the points compiled above might seem to favor one opinion over the other by sheer weight of numbers. But no doubt much could be said in rebuttal of various points on either side. It is possible that this writer’s leanings are by now obvious, but he has made a conscious effort to state fairly the arguments for both sides. This is of course not a matter of “first principle” consequence, so perhaps the best conclusion is this:

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good”.

Job in brief

The book of Job contains such long and involved speeches that it is often hard to see the overall development of the book. In this summary, written as a play, each chapter of Job is distilled down to a paragraph or so. It helps to be able to see the structure and development of thought in the book, and then to go back to better appreciate the full text of Scripture. (Chapters are in parentheses.)


  Narrator: Long ago, Job was one of the richest men alive, yet he was blameless and honest, and a priest to his family. But one day in the assembly, the accuser challenged God. He claimed that Job was righteous only because God had blessed him so much. To prove otherwise, God stripped Job of everything: his possessions, his servants, even his children. Suddenly all was gone. Job was devastated, but he remained faithful and humble. “The Lord gave,” he said, “and now the Lord has taken away. Praise be to his name.” (1)   The accuser was not convinced. “You never hurt Job himself,” he accused God. “Do so, and he will certainly curse you!”   So Job was afflicted with disease. Covered in festering sores from head to foot, he wasted away. But even when his wife scorned him saying, “Curse God and die, Job,” his attitude remained, “Shall we accept good from God, and not trouble?”   And so Job did not sin.   Job had three friends, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar, who heard about his troubles. They came to comfort him, but when they arrived, they found him so disfigured they hardly recognized him! They sat in silence, grieving for him for the ritual week of mourning until, finally, Job broke the silence. (2)   Job: I curse the day I was born! If only I had died at birth! Then at least I would be at rest. Even captives and slaves find release in death, yet my life still goes on! I long for death, but it doesn’t come. Oh why does life continue for those in misery?   This is my worst nightmare! I’ve always been afraid that something like this might happen! I have no peace, no rest, only turmoil. (3)   Eliphaz: Job, I really must respond. Don’t be offended at me. You used to be blameless. That at least should give you some hope. Whatever God is punishing you for, there’s no need to despair.   I learnt in a vision that no one is truly righteous before God, so don’t become resentful now. God certainly punishes the fool and destroys his family, but if it were me, I would appeal to God. Even though he punishes wickedness, he also heals those who accept his discipline. Who knows, before long you’ll be laughing, secure in a new household, living out the fullness of your life. Just apply the lesson to yourself. (4,5)   Job: My words were rash, but I am suffering unimaginable terrors from God. I wish he would finish me off, then at least I would know I had been faithful to the end. As for you: a man should be able to rely on his friends. But you see something dreadful and you speak from your fear. Your words are useless to me.   If you can teach me then I’ll listen, but you must accept that I never departed from my righteous ways. God has appointed a time of misery for me, so now my body is clothed in worms and scabs, and my skin is festering.

  Oh God, life is so short that I must speak out. I would prefer strangling and death to this body of mine! Why do you examine a man so closely? Why do you never give me a moment’s rest? If I have sinned then tell me now, for my life will soon be gone! (6,7)   Bildad: You’re being ridiculous, Job! God is just! When your children sinned, God handed out their penalty. And if you are so pure then God will restore you, but listen to what the fathers have told us. It is those who reject God that are cut down in their prime! God does not reject a blameless man! (8)   Job: I know that no one is truly righteous before God. The wisdom and power of the Creator are so vast, so utterly beyond us. No one can call him to explain himself. He controls the sun and the stars. He performs innumerable miracles and wonders. None of us could possibly stand up in his courtroom and dispute with him. If I tried I could only plead for mercy. This is why I say that God destroys both the blameless and the wicked.   And now, even if I dropped my complaint, I would still dread my sufferings because you have already condemned me! If only there were someone who was able to speak to God on my behalf, to remove his terror from me. Then I could stand up to God, and I would challenge him.   O God, what charges do you have against me? Do you enjoy seeing me suffer? You know my heart. You shaped me from the dust. Are you going to return me to the dust again? I cannot lift up my head because of what you’ve done to me. Leave me alone, and let me die in peace! (9,10)   [pause]   Zophar: Is no one going to respond? Job, you claim to be innocent, but I reckon that God has even forgotten some of your sins! God is greater than you can conceive, so when God chastises you, you cannot challenge him. He reacts to the evil he has witnessed. If only you would put away your sin you could lift up your head without shame. Then God would rescue you. He would protect you for the rest of your life. But the hope of the wicked is nothing more than a dying gasp. (11)   Job: Oh, you’re all so wise! But I have a mind as well! Previously God used to answer me when I called, yet now I suffer your contempt! Men at ease have contempt for misfortune. And the wicked? They live in comfort! Yes, and it is God who makes it so!   However great we are, God is greater. He is able to tear down anyone he has established, whether kings or priests or judges, elders or nobles. I’ve seen all this with my own eyes. And yet, you smear me with lies, you useless healers! I wish you would remain silent rather than distort God’s work. How will you fare when his dread falls on you? Your words are proverbs made from ashes.   [Eliphaz tries to interrupt]   No! Let me finish.   Even if God slays me I will still hope in him, and still defend myself before him. Can anyone honestly condemn me? If so I will be silent and die.   Oh God, let me have a little rest, and then I will answer you. Show me my offence. Show me my sin, because I’m rotting away to nothing. You know that man is a fleeting shadow. Cut him down and he does not rise again. To the end of creation he lies in the dust.   Oh if only you would hide me in the grave, hide me until your anger has passed, until a time comes to remember me.. Yes, I will wait. I will wait for my renewal. You will call and I will answer you. You will see the steps I’ve taken. And you will throw away my sins like a bag of rubbish. Oh, but you’re wearing me down. You’re destroying this man’s hope through the pain of his body… (12-14)   [Pause, to be sure Job has finished]   Eliphaz: You windbag! Your own mouth condemns you, and your words undermine devotion to God. How come you know so much about him? Do you sit in his council?   Oh Job. How come your heart has carried you away so that your eyes flash with anger at God? Even the heavens are not pure enough for God, much less man. Ask any wise man, or any of the fathers. It is a wicked man that God takes from comfort and security to plunge into distress and anguish. His strength is useless because God will pay him in full before his time. (15)   Job: I’ve heard all this before, you miserable comforters! Why don’t you cease? If we changed places then I would encourage and comfort you. Instead, not only do I suffer at the hand of God, but you jeer and sneer at me. God has devastated my family and destroyed my flesh. My face is red with weeping, even though my hands are free from violence, and my prayers pure. My blood cries out from the ground. Even now my account is in heaven. If only there were someone to plead with God on my behalf, as a man pleads for his friend. Instead, I’m about to die and I’m surrounded by mockers, bearing the brunt of your hostility. (16)   O God, you are the only one who can save me!   But God has made me a byword, a man in whose face people spit, a man to shock the upright. So come on then. Try again. But I’ll get no wisdom from you. Death is my best option now. (17)   Bildad: Be sensible, Job. Why do you call us stupid? You’re just tearing yourself to pieces in your anger. It is the lamp of the wicked that is snuffed out. Calamity overcomes him, eats away at his skin, and strips him of his children so that his memory is lost from the land. This is the fate of an evil man. (18)   Job: How long will you torment me with words? If indeed you would exalt yourselves above me, then let me tell you that God has wronged me! God caught me in his net and alienated me from my relatives, from my friends, and even from my wife. Those I love have turned away from me. My breath is sour and I am nothing but skin and bones. Have pity on me, my friends, and stop hounding me.   How I wish my words were written down. I know that my redeemer lives, and that in the end he will stand on the earth. Then I will awake. I will see God with my own eyes — I and not another.   But you. You should fear the sword yourselves. Then you will know that there is judgment. (19)   Zophar: Again I must speak. You disturb and dishonor me by your rebuke. You must know that, from the beginning, the joy of the wicked is brief. In his pride he reaches for the heavens, but he is banished like a dream and his children must make up for his evil. Though he revels in oppression, terrors will overcome him. The heavens will expose his guilt and God’s wrath will consume him. (20)   Job: Let me try once more, then you can continue to mock me. Despite openly rejecting God, the wicked enjoy prosperity. Their children still grow up and sing to the music of tambourine and harp. Be honest. How often is the lamp of the wicked snuffed out? Instead, two men lie down in the dust of death, side by side, one lived in security and plenty, while the other died in bitterness, never having enjoyed anything good.   I know what you’re thinking, that I bear all the marks of punishment for sin. But just travel a little and you will see that evil men are spared calamity. So how can you console me with your nonsense? (21)   Eliphaz: So God is punishing you for your righteousness! Job, the list of your sins is endless! You stripped your own brothers naked, you gave no water to the weary, no food to the hungry. You sent widows away empty handed, and you worked orphans into the ground. You wonder whether God sees you, but he does. Why continue in wickedness? Even now, Job, submit to God, and you will be restored and light will shine on your ways. You will then be able to save others likewise. (22)   Job: Look, if only I knew where to find God I would state my case before him, and he would listen! But I can’t find him anywhere, even though I treasured his words more than my daily bread. He remains aloof and unreachable. (23)   I wish that God would indeed set times for judgment. Terrible injustices occur, but God charges no one with wrongdoing. Men prey on the needy and the destitute. They murder, they creep around in adultery. You say that God is bound to bring them low, but he does not. You cannot contradict that. (24)   Bildad: God is a God of order, and of power, and of righteousness! But man? He is a maggot! (25)   Job: How you have helped me! What great wisdom! God is so far above our understanding. How can any of us explain his acts? (26)   As long as I live I will not speak wickedness, and neither will I deny my integrity. Hypocrisy would completely cut me off from God. (27)   You have seen God’s ways, so why do you speak such rubbish. Why do you say that suffering is allotted only to the wicked, that only the children of the wicked die by the sword or go hungry, that it is only the wicked that are blown away? Where can true wisdom be found? You can’t mine it out of the ground, or purchase it with gold. God alone knows where it is, and so He tells man, “Fear the Lord — that is wisdom.” (28)   I long for the days when God’s intimate friendship blessed my house. I was respected in the city. I helped the poor. I rescued orphans. I acted as eyes to the blind, and as feet to the lame. I helped the needy, and broke the fangs of their exploiters. I expected to live peaceful to a ripe old age. But now? Instead of hanging on my every word, they mock me, mere youths! They detest me and spit in my face. (29)   I am frightened. My life ebbs away. Pains gnaw at my bones and God throws me in the mud. Even though I cry out to him he tosses me into the storm. I used to weep for those in trouble, but when it was my turn to hope for good, evil came. (30)   I kept myself from sin because I know God watches my every step. If I am guilty — and if God would weigh me honestly he would know I am not — then indeed let others eat my food. If I am an adulterer then let them take my wife from me; if I have denied any charity then indeed let my body be broken. But how could I have denied justice to others when I know that God is the Judge who formed us all?   If I had trusted in wealth, that would be sin; or if I gloated over my enemy or cursed him; or if I had not shown hospitality; or if I had hidden sin in my heart — whatever it is let my accuser declare it so that I can answer him — or if I had devoured land without payment then, certainly, let briers come up instead of barley. (31)   That’s all I have to say.   [A young man, Elihu, has been listening. After realizing that no one is going to respond to Job, he bursts out]   Elihu: I’m younger than you elders so I kept quiet, but age doesn’t give wisdom, God does. You have utterly failed to answer Job, so now let me speak before I burst! And I can assure you I have no intention of flattering anyone! Job, I ask you to listen to me. I’m a man just like yourself. I heard you claim to be sinless, and accuse God for faulting you. You have no right to say such things. Why do you strive against God? He uses visions and events, even chastenings, to turn a man from his pride, providing a messenger to teach him. And not just once, he will do so again and again. (32)   Listen to me, Job! If you have anything to say, then say it, but otherwise let me teach you wisdom. Listen to me all of you, and let us discern together what is right. Job claims that God denies him justice, and even claims that there is no value in serving God! But it is unthinkable that God would do wrong. It is he who gives men their very breath, and is able to take it away in an instant, however great and noble they are. Would you really condemn God in his justice? He can judge without trial because he watches men even in secret, but whether he punishes or remains silent is for him to decide. Wise men say that Job speaks out of ignorance, and now he adds rebellion to his sin. (33)   Job, you claim that God will clear your name. But at the same time you also imply you get no benefit by avoiding sin! It’s actually the other way around! How can you possibly affect the Great Creator by either your righteousness or your sin? It is only other people who would suffer your wickedness. If God is prepared to close his ears to the cries of the wicked, how much more will he ignore your self-righteous indignation. Job is an ignorant babbler. (34,35)   Bear with me a little longer. There’s more to be said on God’s behalf, and through his inspiration I will speak. Even though God is mighty, he doesn’t despise men, but he does use suffering to turn people from evil. The godless resent this, and refuse to respond. Now that you are laden with the judgment of the wicked, beware of turning to evil as a means of escaping affliction.   [The sky begins to darken with an approaching storm]

  God is the ultimate teacher, with powers and abilities far beyond our understanding. He forms the rain, the clouds, and thunder. Look! See how his lightning flashes around. This is the power he uses to govern the nations! (36)   [Thunder crashes. Elihu shouts to be heard as the noise continues to increase]   Listen to the roar of his voice! It makes my heart pound! God works throughout the whole world; he does great things beyond our understanding. He sends rain and snow, stopping men from their labor, and sending the animals to their dens. He brings clouds both to punish, and to water the earth in love. Listen Job! Stop and consider God’s wonders. Can you match his power? Can you really expect to call him to account? We can’t even stare at the sun in its brightness. (37)   And now! Here is God coming! God who is beyond our reach, and is full of justice and righteousness! This is why men revere him. And in turn he cares for those who are wise in heart.   [The storm is upon them. God speaks from the whirling cloud]

  The Lord: Who is this who darkens my counsel with ignorant words? Brace yourself, Job. I’m calling you to account!   Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know! Who shut up the sea behind doors, and wrapped the sky in clouds? Have you given orders to the morning, or walked on the bed of the sea? Have the gates of death been shown to you, or even the storehouses of hail and snow? But you are so wise! You have lived so many years!

  What about the stars, great Orion and the Bear and other constellations? Can you guide them in season? You can’t even count them! Can you control the clouds and the lightning? Perhaps you feed the lioness or the raven, or maybe you help the mountain goats give birth? Perhaps you know why the ostrich is so foolish, or the horse so strong? Is it your wisdom that allows the hawk to fly and to hunt, or the eagle to soar? You wanted to wrestle with me, Job, so now I want an answer from you. (38,39)   Job: I am unworthy. I cannot answer you.   The Lord: Brace yourself, Job. I want an answer. Would you discredit my justice, or condemn me in order to justify yourself? If you have power like mine then use it. Bring the proud man down! Bury him in the dust with the wicked! If you can do this, then I will admit that you can save yourself.   I made a mighty beast when I made you. His great bones are brass and iron. He exercises dominion over the works of God, demanding tribute from the other beasts. The raging flood is nothing to him. Can anyone take him with hooks, or trap him in a snare? What about it, Job? Can you tie him down? Will he make a lasting covenant with you? Will you make him your plaything when he terrifies you?   It is in my mercy that I allow him to plague mankind, but I limit him, despite all his boasting about his teeth, his armor, his breath setting coals ablaze. The mighty are terrified before him, and neither sword nor spear has any effect on him. He makes the deep sea boil, and he is a beast without fear. With his heaven-confronting eyes, he is king of the proud. (40,41)   Job: I know that you can do all things. No one can oppose you. I did not really understand before. Now that I have seen you I despise myself. I repent in dust and ashes.   [God turns to Eliphaz]   The Lord: Eliphaz, I am furious with you and your two friends because you spoke lies about me. But if you bring sacrifices, my servant Job will pray for you, and I will listen to him and not deal with you according to your foolish ideas.   Narrator: So Job prayed for his friends, and the Lord accepted his prayer. Afterwards, the Lord made Job prosperous again, giving him twice as much as he had before. Everyone who knew him came to him and gave him gifts. He also had seven sons and three beautiful daughters. Job lived long enough to see his great grandchildren. And when he finally died, he was old and full of years. (42) (JL)

Jephthah’s vow (HAW)

As [Jephthah] approached his home [following his great victory] the maidens of the town came forth, according to the custom of the time, to greet the mighty man of valour with songs and dances. In this way, Miriam and the women of Israel had celebrated the destruction of Pharaoh’s host in the Red Sea (Exo 15:20); and later, David’s victories over the Philistines were acclaimed in the same fashion (1Sa 18:6).

But now, to his consternation and grief, Jephthah beheld amongst them his own daughter, and he who should have been enjoying the victor’s triumph rent his clothes: “Alas, my daughter! thou hast brought me very low, and thou art one of them that trouble me: for I have opened my mouth unto the Lord, and I cannot go back.”

However Jephthah’s vow be understood, that last phrase shows what a sterling character he was. “I cannot go back!” Come what may, his vow to God must be performed. Jephthah swore to his own hurt, and changed not. “He that doeth these things shall never be moved.” For this Jephthah’s name is inscribed in the Lord’s “roll of honour” in Hebrews 11 amongst those who glorified God by their faith.

The question of the fate of Jephthah’s daughter as a result of the vow he made unto the Lord is probably the most discussed problem in the Book of Judges. Traditionally the vow of Jephthah has been taken as meaning exactly what it says. Nevertheless there are those who believe that Jephthah’s daughter was not slain and burnt on an altar, but that she was dedicated to life-long service of God in connection with the tabernacle. This latter conclusion has the weight of evidence behind it. It is those who believe that the maiden became a burnt offering who are faced with difficulties.

First, it is tolerably clear that Jephthah was expecting to have to give to God, in fulfilment of his vow, a PERSON and not an animal; or to be more precise, BOTH a person AND a burnt offering. His words were: “Whatsoever cometh forth of the doors of my house to meet me… shall surely be the Lord’s.” There is no point in stressing “whatsoever (as distinct from whomsoever) cometh forth”: the word “whatsoever” is a Hebrew masculine, for in such a sentence the masculine would cover all genders.

But what animal might come to meet Jephthah? The only animals that might be offered as a burnt offering were sheep, goats, bullocks, and (for the very poorest of the people) pigeons. Would Jephthah be expecting to be met by any of these? The only animal that might conceivably go out to meet him would be a favourite hound, and that would certainly not make an acceptable offering to the Lord.

In any case, Jephthah’s vow manifestly signified something of considerable value in his eyes — a real sacrifice, in the modern sense of the world.

Since, from the very nature of the vow, it must refer to someone over whom Jephthah had full control, the possibilities are limited to two: a favourite slave, or servant, or his only daughter.

Consequently, the conclusion becomes inevitable that Jephthah was vowing unto God someone for whom he would have real affection, someone whose loss he would mourn bitterly. His vow was a vow worth making. It honoured God by an offering that was by no means inconsiderable.

Once this vow is thus seen in its true perspective, all other details begin to fall into place.

It has already been seen [from his astute handling of Scripture earlier in Jdg 11] that Jephthah was no uncouth desperado, but — like the outlaw David — a devout man well-schooled in the Scriptures. He would therefore be no stranger to such passages as the following: “Thou shalt not let any of thy seed pass through the fire to Molech, neither shalt thou profane the name of thy God: I am the Lord” (Lev 18:21).

“Take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them, after that they be destroyed from before thee; and that thou inquire not after their gods, saying, How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise. Thou shalt not do so unto the Lord thy God: for every abomination to the Lord, which he hateth, have they done unto their gods; for even their sons and their daughters have they burnt in the fire to their gods” (Deu 12:30,31).

“There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch” (Deu 18:10).

Then is it possible that such a man as Jephthah would even consider making a human sacrifice? Is it likely that having just returned from the slaughter of the Ammonites (whose god had been unable to deliver or prosper them), he would then proceed to imitate the rites of Molech, the god of Ammon, which were utterly forbidden to Israel?

Again, let it be supposed that Jephthah had sought to offer his daughter as a burnt-offering. This could be done only at the altar of the Lord, and through the ministration of a priest — and what priest would condone or assist such a flagrant breach of Levitical precept?

And, if the maiden were to die as a sacrifice, would it not be an intensely unnatural thing for her to spend the last two months of her life away from her father who loved her so much?

It needs to be recognized also that the vowing of persons to God was a perfectly normal matter in the life of Israel; the Law made provision for such acts of exceptional piety: “Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them, When a man shall make a singular vow, the persons shall be for the Lord by thy estimation” (Lev 27:2). A commutation price, differing for males and females and according to the age of the person vowed unto the Lord, might be paid. In the case of a male between the ages of twenty and sixty, this payment was fifty shekels (for a working man, more than a year’s wages?).

Evidently then, the vow took the form of consecrating, in effect, the labour value of the person vowed. The practical result, in most instances, would be for the commutation price to be paid and the life of the individual concerned would proceed normally.

But, it has been claimed, the same scripture REQUIRES the actual sacrifice of such as Jephthah’s daughter: “Notwithstanding, no devoted thing that a man shall devote unto the Lord of all that he hath, both of man and beast, and of the field of his possession, shall be sold, or redeemed: every devoted thing is most holy unto the Lord. None devoted, which shall be devoted of men, shall be redeemed; abut all shall surely be put to death” (Lev 27:18,19).

To apply these words to the question under discussion is to confuse two very different things, namely (1) that which is vowed; and (2) the devoted thing (Hebrew “cherem”; eg, Josh 6:17,18 same word).

Whereas there was always optional redemption of a vow by means of a money payment, the “cherem” — nearly always associated with what was taken in war — normally meant utter destruction (something akin to whole burnt offering). Jephthah’s vow was the former of these. Lev 27:18,19 describes the latter.

There were instances, like Hannah’s vowing of her son unto the Lord “all the days of his life”, when advantage of the commutation arrangement was not taken. This is what Jephthah meant when he said: “I cannot go back.” His daughter was to be given to the Lord all the days of her life. So completely did Jephthah feel his indebtedness to the Lord that there was to be no suggestion of taking an easy way out. He would pay his vow in the fullest sense, by giving his daughter from that time forward for permanent service in the precincts of the tabernacle. (WJR).

Job’s satan

Job’s “satan”: an angel of evil? (but not, of course, a “wicked” angel!):

  • Job’s “satan” comes into the presence of God, and is in conversation with Him, among the “sons of God” (Job 1:6). Elsewhere in Job the sons of God are plainly His angels (Job 38:4-7). True, “sons of God” can refer to human believers (as in 1Jo 3:2), but Job should interpret Job first!
  • Job’s affliction is consistently attributed to God (Job 4:9; 5:17; 6:4; 7:20; 11:6; 19:21; and esp Job 42:11).

Difficulties?

  • Why is an angel of God called “Satan” (or “satan”)? Because this designation well described his actions here — he was Job’s “adversary” (cp also Num 22:22).
  • Isn’t there a wicked or sinful mind behind his words (Job 1:9-11; 2:5)? Answer: The words CAN be read that way, but they do not HAVE to be read that way. Although “angels of God” are immortal, they can be limited both in their personal knowledge and in their personal powers. (Consider Mat 24:36; 1Pe 1:12; Dan 10:13; 8:13; Gen 22:12; 32:24-28; Exo 31:1,7 compared with Exo 23:12). So it is possible to read the words of this angelic “satan” as expressing his assessment of the life of Job… distorted a bit by his own limited knowledge.

I would suggest that in all that this “satan” says of Job there is no sign of wickedness, only limited understanding seeking clarification. He declares his unwillingness to believe that Job’s “righteousness” is anything but self-serving:

“Then Satan answered the LORD, Does Job fear God for nought? Hast thou not put a hedge about him and his house and all that he has, on every side? Thou hast blessed the work of his hands, and his possessions have increased in the land. But put forth thy hand now, and touch all that he has, and he will curse thee to thy face” (Job 1:9-11).

As if to say, ‘All my experience of this race of humans tells me that when they serve God they do so only for selfish reasons. Let us see how he reacts to severe trials.’

And so God gives over to this “angel” the testing of Job:

“Behold, all that he has is in your power; only upon himself do not put forth your hand” (v 12).

Now compare this v 12 with v 21: “The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away; blessed be the name of the LORD.” Who was it that took away Job’s health, wealth, and family?

And with Job 2:10: “Shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil?”

And also with Job 19:21, where Job says: “Have pity on me, have pity on me, O you my friends, for the hand of God has touched me!” Doesn’t this equate the “satan” with “the hand of God”?

And so, all through Job 2, “Satan” continues to hold out for his own assessment of things, while God agrees to bring more and yet more trial upon Job… until, eventually, it may be assumed, “Satan” is finally satisfied with the integrity of Job.

Is this fair? Is this the way God acts? Of course. The NT is filled with discussions of the trials brought by God on His faithful ones, to perfect or purify their faith.

And from his trials, extreme though they were, Job emerges as a man of tested and perfected faith… a fitting type of the Lord Jesus Christ, who was to come, and who would himself suffer “unfairly” and “unjustly” as a way of showing (to men… and to angels?) the way into the most holy place of the Father.

Also, please note 1Pe 1:6-12:

“In this you rejoice, though now for a little while you may have to suffer various trials, so that the genuineness of your faith, more precious than gold which though perishable is tested by fire, may redound to praise and glory and honor at the revelation of Jesus Christ. Without having seen him you love him; though you do not now see him you believe in him and rejoice with unutterable and exalted joy. As the outcome of your faith you obtain the salvation of your souls. The prophets who prophesied of the grace that was to be yours searched and inquired about this salvation; they inquired what person or time was indicated by the Spirit of Christ within them when predicting the sufferings of Christ and the subsequent glory. It was revealed to them that they were serving not themselves but you, in the things which have now been announced to you by those who preached the good news to you through the Holy Spirit sent from heaven, things into which angels long to look.”

In this passage (and, compared with Job) we see:

  • severe trials by which the faith of the believer is purified.
  • the prophets (OT writers?) who saw, faintly perhaps, the sufferings of Christ mirrored in the lives of OT men (like Job?).
  • the sufferings were followed by subsequent glory.
  • … AND… “into these things (sufferings, trials, perfecting of faith, of righteous men who pointed forward to the Messiah) ANGELS LONGED TO LOOK!”

Jer, overview

Author: Jeremiah and Baruch

Time: 630 – 575 BC

Summary: Jeremiah warns of the impending military force of Babylon that would destroy Jerusalem and enslave the Jews. He urges Jerusalem to turn from its wicked ways, but there is no response. He further warns of the false prophets who are leading the people astray with deceptive doctrines and falsehoods. He urges the Israelites to submit to the Babylonian authority as the instrument of God’s judgment. They do not heed his warnings and the people are carried away to Babylon. He predicts that the captives will return after 70 years to rebuild Jerusalem and the Temple.

Outline

1. The prophet’s call: Jer 1
2. Prophetic oracles against Jerusalem and Judah: Jer 2-35
a) Early discourses: Jer 2-6
b) Temple message: Jer 7-10
c) Covenant and conspiracy: Jer 11-13
d) Messages concerning the drought: Jer 14-15
e) Disaster and comfort: Jer 16:1-17:18
f) Command to keep the Sabbath holy: Jer 17:19-27
g) Lessons from the potter: Jer 18-20
h) Condemnation of kings, prophets and people: Jer 21-24
i) Foretelling the Babylonian exile: Jer 25-29
j) Promises of restoration: Jer 30-33
k) Historical appendix: Jer 34-35
3. Sufferings and persecutions of Jeremiah: Jer 36-38
a) Burning Jeremiah’s scroll: Jer 36
b) Imprisoning Jeremiah: Jer 37-38
4. The fall of Jerusalem and its aftermath: Jer 39-45
a) The fall itself: Jer 39
b) Accession and assassination of Gedaliah: Jer 40:1-41:15
c) Migration to Egypt: Jer 41:16-43:13
d) Prophecy against those in Egypt: Jer 44
e) Historical appendix: promise to Baruch: Jer 45
5. Prophecies against the nations: Jer 46-51
a) Against Egypt: Jer 46:1-28
b) Against Philistia: Jer 47:1-7
c) Against Moab: Jer 48:1-47
d) Against Ammon: Jer 49:1-6
e) Against Edom: Jer 49:7-22
f) Against Damascus: Jer 49:23-27
g) Against Arabia: Jer 49:28-33
h) Against Elam: Jer 49:34-39
i) Against Babylon: Jer 50-51
6. Historical appendix: Jer 52
a) Judah’s fall and captivity: Jer 52:1-30
b) Jehoiachin’s liberation: Jer 52:31-34

Jeremiah’s chapters in chronological order

1-6; 11; 12; 26; 7-10; 14-20; 35; 36; 45; 25; 46-49; 13; 22-24; 27-29; 50; 51; 30-33; 21; 34; 37-39; 52; 40-44.

Job, exhortation (GVG)

“I have uttered that I understood not; things too wonderful for me, which I knew not… Wherefore I abhor myse!f, and repent in dust and ashes” (Job 42:3-6).

We are once again reading together the marvelous book of Job. It is the only non-Jewish book of the Bible, and it is in all probability the oldest book of the Bible. Many eminent men — both religious and non-religious — have called it the supreme literary production in all the world’s history. It is, from any point of view, a most remarkable piece of writing.

The place and time

From the names of the characters and their ancestors, and the place names, the location of the story is the area between the Dead Sea and the desert, or somewhat to the north or south of that: the area of the descendants of Abraham other than through Jacob — generally speaking, the Arabs. Job was one of the “Men of the East,” a term applied to the Arabs: Ishmaelites, Edomites, etc. And the time seems most likely to be during the two hundred or so years Israel was in Egypt. All the background and customs and genealogy point to this place and time.

As to how the book of Job got into an otherwise wholly Jewish Bible, there is a strong and ancient Jewish tradition that Moses wrote it, or at least made it part of the Scriptures — by the guidance of the Spirit of course. Moses would have been the logical one to do so. He may well have known Job himself, or Job’s early descendants, during the forty years he was in Midian. Job was the greatest (and therefore best known) of the “Men of the East” (Job 1:3), and Midian would be included in that area. The history of Job would be well-known there.

It is remarkable that the great typical and exemplary patient sufferer of the Old Testament is not a Jew, but rather is of a race which — though closely related — was always, and still is, in deep antagonism to the Jews. He was a Gentile — a non-Jew, that is — of the seed of Abraham, adding to the beauty and fitness of the typical picture.

A non-Jewish model of excellence

Here, in the midst of an otherwise Jewish book, is a perfect model of excellence for all time: a man who is not a Jew, not under the Law, who had nothing to do with the Law, nothing to do with Israel. He is referred to by Ezekiel (Eze 14:14), with Noah and Daniel, as three outstanding examples of righteousness. He is referred to by James (Jam 5:11) as the ultimate example of patient, faithful suffering.

The story opens with the… picture of [sons] of God coming together before Him, and among them [an]… adversary… Orthodoxy represents its Devil as having free access to God’s heaven, and being God’s agent and accomplice. One respectable modern commentary, the “New Bible Commentary,” says concerning this scene that the Devil is a “divine agent,” and is the supreme cynic of the heavenly court.” What a debased, pagan conception of God’s holy dwelling-place! — in perfect harmony with the crude gods and heavens of Greece and Rome, but certainly not with the Scriptures of Truth.

“Doth Job fear God for nought?” He DID: and so must we. Our motive must be love alone, and not self-benefit, though self-benefit will inevitably follow, for goodness can lead only at last to goodness, in a world ruled by the goodness of God. But our motivation must be pure love of God and of goodness.

Why do the righteous suffer?

The great question of the book of Job is: Why do the righteous suffer? And the great lesson is: We must totally and unquestioningly trust God, and have implicit faith in His love, mercy and justice, regardless of any appearances or circumstances. He has a reason and a purpose in the suffering of His people: different reasons at different times, but all working toward their ultimate glorification — often a reason (as here) that would be impossible for man ever to guess without knowing what was in God’s mind.

The sufferings of Christ point to the same problem: Why? We can dimly perceive how he was “made perfect through suffering,” and how his perfect submission to that suffering laid the eternal foundation for the world’s redemption from all suffering.

But, above all, we must unhesitatingly accept the ways of God because He is God; because He manifestly has made all things, and knows the reason for all. He has manifested His infinite power and wisdom in all the beauties and glories of Creation. He proclaims His love and justice in His Word. He overwhelmingly manifests His divinity in that Word.

We must accept the whole picture, or reject the whole picture. To reject it in the light of its overpowering evidence is stupidity. To question God’s ways in the light of His overpowering greatness is obviously equal stupidity. This is the lesson of Job. The final outcome manifested God’s wisdom and love and compassion. We must have implicit trust that it always will if we do our part faithfully.

It was a high honor and privilege for Job to be used by God to demonstrate for all ages what true righteousness and faith really is, and to give an example of patient integrity in the face of what appeared to everyone, including Job himself, a deliberate divine effort to afflict and torment him to the uttermost.

Job and Christ: striking parallels

We see throughout, a very striking, broad parallel between Job and Christ, although there are necessarily differences and contrasts.

Both were the outstandingly righteous men of their age.

Both suffered more intensely and grievously than is recorded of any other man. Christ suffered more greatly, and more extendedly, for he lived his whole life in the shadow of the inevitable cross, under the constant burden of required perfection, or all Creation would have been betrayed. And in his deep and superhuman empathy, he suffered all the sufferings of his people of all ages. Infinitely more even than Paul he could say: “Who is weak, and I am not weak? Who is offended, and I burn not?” He was pre-eminently a Man of Sorrows (Isa 53:3), though at the same time a Man of incomparable Joy (Joh 15:11; 17:13).

With both, God knew from the beginning that they would hold fast to the end, regardless of the intensity of the trial: and God built His purpose upon that assurance. What a glorious role for men to play! If Job had failed… God would have been put to shame; His whole dispensation of love exposed as mere self-serving.

Both were reduced in shame from the highest position to the lowest, though in different ways. Christ, as the only begotten Son of God, was the potential heir of the universe. As Paul explains to the Philippians (Phi 2:6-8), Jesus — though finding himself the one special man above all men, even the “Fellow” of God (Zec 13:7), entitled to the homage of the angels (Heb 1) — nevertheless humbled himself, and accepted the position of a slave, even to the most ignominious of deaths.

Both were utterly despised and rejected. Both were assumed by their own people and generation to be under the special curse of God, at the very time they were suffering for the sake of others. For we must recognize that Job’s sufferings went far beyond himself, and were for universal instruction and comfort and guidance. It was not an aimless wager, when God staked all on Job’s integrity, but an essential manifestation of the noble, vital, spiritual principle of faithful integrity for its own sake alone, under the most extreme of testings: the key to salvation. We must do good simply because we love the good and hate the evil.

Made perfect by suffering

Both were “made perfect by suffering.” This is a deep and important aspect in both cases. Christ, though of unblemished righteousness, was not “perfect” until he had, in loving and all-trusting obedience, passed through the required suffering and sacrificial death.

Job was the most righteous man of his day: a giant of faith and endurance — “perfect and upright,” “none like him in all the earth,” according to the testimony of God Himself (Job 1:8). Still, Job has something to learn, something in which to be developed and brought to beautiful fruition, as he at last freely and humbly confesses (Job 40:4; 42:6).

Unquestionably, Job was a better, wiser, greater, more understanding man, much closer to God, after his terrible trial than before. And he had attained to a far higher position in the Divine Purpose and Manifestation. As a prosperous and honored sheik, he never would have fully known God. He never would have become an inspiration and example for all ages. He never would have been granted the unique and inestimable privilege of the direct Divine revelation he received.

God’s unique self-manifestation to Job

Was ever a man the subject of so full and personal and searching a Divine address to himself? God did not deign to explain, for that would have been utterly inappropriate, and would not have accomplished the desired result. We must first accept God and all His ways fully and unquestioningly, before we can hope for any explanation of their mysteries.

But God condescended to take the time and trouble to fully and in detail manifest Himself and His majesty to Job, as He did to none other we know of but Christ himself. God’s address to Job is unique in all Scripture.

Job at last received that which he had so passionately pleaded for: a direct divine manifestation. It would be well worth all the scorn and abuse and terrible suffering he had endured. Indeed, its value and power would be greatly heightened by that dark background. What a joyful, glorious, inspiring, comforting memory for the last one hundred and forty years of his life! — a life which he thought was already over. How much closer he would now be to God for that long period of recompense for his trials! How much more at peace — for there are hints that for all his religious efforts and prosperity, he was not before truly at peace. In the anguish of his suffering, he makes such revelations as this:

“That which I GREATLY FEARED is come upon me” (Job 3:25).

But never again would he fear anything. Now his peace was deep and strong. The ordeal was dreadful, but we see its wholesome benefits.

Job’s crushing avalanche of affliction

Job’s afflictions were many and cumulative. They would quickly have destroyed a lesser man. In evaluating Job and what he at times says, we must strive to comprehend the almost incomprehensible extent to which he was tortured and tried in so many ways at once.

First, he lost all his possessions and livelihood. In swift succession, calamity upon calamity fell crushingly upon him. And with it, he lost his whole family of ten beloved children in what was obviously a direct divine blow, unexplained and unprovoked: his cherished family for which he had constantly prayed and offered sacrifice.

His reaction was perfect, unhesitating, total acceptance and worship —

“The Lord gave, the Lord hath taken away; blessed be the name of the Lord.”

Then, in seeming heartless response by God to this loving and godly reaction, he was smitten from head to foot — again obviously by the hand of God — with the most painful, loathsome and abhorred disease known to man, inevitably fatal in terrible suffering in the natural course of events: a particularly repulsive form of consuming, deforming leprosy, universally regarded as a manifestation of God’s especial wrath.

Then his wife turned against him — and all his friends and acquaintances. And he found himself a universally abandoned pariah, cast out of the city, consigned to the refuse heap to die a lingering death: the butt of ridicule and abuse by the vilest class of the people, who tormented him for their depraved amusement.

Job was totally rejected, and driven “without the gate” by those who considered themselves the “Holy City.”

In the raw meanness of ordinary human nature, everyone was gratified to see this mighty man, this presumed paragon of righteousness, crushed and humbled in the mire, and eager to add their own miserable quota to his overflowing misery. They spit in his face, he says. Exactly the same thing is said of Christ (Mat 26:67): the deepest degradation and insult. “Crucify him! Crucify him! He pretended to be so good!” It was his very God-attested goodness that so enraged the blind evil fury of the flesh against him.

The friends come

And so time dragged on wearily, with Job lying in misery in the ashes (Job 2:8) (the Septuagint says “dung-heap,” which is probably the meaning), until his three special friends heard of his calamities, and assembled to comfort him. They were so struck with his misery and dreadful appearance that they sat around him in silence for seven days. Then, when he repeatedly implored their comfort and sympathy, they more and more heatedly condemned him and accused him of the vilest crimes and hypocrisies.

This is the background against which we must consider him. Truly, like Moses, under tremendous stress he “spake unadvisedly with his lips.”

Job is throughout wrestling tremendously with this problem. Upon the shame and misery of his condition is heaped the smug and self-righteous condemnation of his closest friends. His friends’ rejection aroused an over-reaction in what he said, but threw him more and more on God. He had sought their support and sympathy against the hand of God. They railed on him, thinking they were thereby earning God’s favor. This added to his bitterness, but it showed him there was nowhere to turn for comfort and understanding but to God Himself.

The friends’ condemnation was an essential part of the trial, and of the final result. Though it added immeasurably to his grief, it was probably more helpful to him (in a way opposite what they intended) than their sympathy would have been.

Job’s greatest agony: God’s seeming rejection

All forsook him in his extremity. But his greatest agony was not in his sufferings, nor in his rejection by all mankind, but God’s apparent rejection and forsaking and enmity. Again and again he implores God for but one word of hope or comfort or recognition, but is met with total silence, and increased oppression. Even when he seeks brief, exhausted surcease in sleep, he is terrified with awful dreams (Job 7:14).

To judge what he says, we must consider all he said, and the order in which he said it; just as we must consider the whole of Psa 22, and not just the first few words from it that Christ quoted on the cross. It is all too easy to get his cries of anguish out of proportion, as if they were the studied and final conclusions reached coolly and theoretically in ease and comfort.

The fundamental fact is that Job held fast his trust in God, and would not deviate from his dedication to righteousness (which has no meaning outside of faith in God); and he was confident throughout of final resurrection, and of God’s open manifestation to him at last.

There is no more triumphant victory of faith than is expressed in his memorable words, wrung from him In the depth of present despair —

“Though he slay me, yet will I trust him… He also shall be my salvation!”

“If a man die, shall he live again? All the days of my appointed time will I wait, till my change come. Thou shalt call, and I will answer Thee. Thou wilt have a desire (kasaph: longing) to the work of Thine hands.”

“I KNOW that my redeemer liveth, and that He shall stand at the latter day UPON THE EARTH… Whom I shall see for myself, and mine eyes shall behold” (Job 13:15-16; 14:14-15; 19:25-27).

Why such dreadful affliction?

His complaints are not against God’s overall justice, but against His seeming injustice in the affairs of this life — especially that one who tried so hard to obey should be picked out for the most terrible of afflictions, while all men gloated, and the wicked were at ease. Job knew that at last all would be righted, but why this special, dreadful, unprovoked affliction of a righteous and faithful man?

The friends fall silent. Job restates his case at length (Job 26-31) with great power and beauty: conceding that the wicked are finally punished; conceding God’s infinite might and understanding; conceding that man’s whole wisdom is to fear God and depart from evil — but again long and stoutly declaring his own righteousness, and crying for the opportunity of debating his case with God, confident of victory.

Then a new figure enters, the young Elihu, who prepares Job for the final revelation from God. He introduces the idea that suffering is not only for punishment, as the friends contended, but has many uses in the love and wisdom of God: constructive loving discipline, directional chastisement of a Father, strengthening by training and rigor, manifestation and deepening of faith, purification — especially purification, making perfect. Suffering can and must lead to fuller understanding, and thus be a blessing. Job makes no attempt to answer Elihu.

God speaks

Then God speaks. It is notable that Job was given just what he asked: an opportunity to stand up to God and argue with Him, to show Him how He must be mistaken. But how swiftly Job’s bold self-assurance fled before the mighty manifestation of God’s infinite wisdom and power!

That God should deign to speak to man at all — especially to one calling His ways in question — is a tremendous condescension in itself, a tremendous and unique honor, and manifestation of love for Job.

As God spoke of the endless marvels of His Creation, Job shrank to nothing. Crushed in shame, he learned to rest totally and unreservedly in God, devastated by the sudden realization of the stupidity and presumption of daring to challenge God and question His ways.

When God brought Job to the comfort and peace of unquestioning love and trust, He thereby solved all Job’s problems, even before He removed Job’s afflictions. Their removal came later, after Job had waived all his complaints, and prostrated himself in loving worship.

God banished Job’s questions, not by answering them, but by totally removing them from his concern. Job was wholly satisfied that whatever God did must be right, and must be rooted in love and wisdom.

God’s answer was to give no answer, but to manifest a God so great that no answer was needed. To need an explanation and justification of anything God does is to have a degraded and unacceptable conception of God. He is infinitely above all question and accountability.

Man dare not question God

Job was faithful and righteous above all his contemporaries, and completely, actively dedicated to good works, and to service to God and man. He demonstrated his firm and unshakable endurance, and that he unselfishly loved goodness for goodness’ sake alone. But he did not have the necessary total self-abasing humility and recognition of self-nothingness until he was crushed by the divine revelation. The learning of this was the supreme blessing of his entire experience.

The whole lesson of God’s self-manifestation to Job is the limitless greatness of God, and the utter littleness of man. If God had stooped to explain Himself to Job before totally humbling him in the recognition of his nothingness, then God would have been conceding man’s right to judge God and demand an answer for His ways. And man must be made to realize that he just does not have this right. It is absurd and unthinkable that puny little ignorant created man should for one moment question God, Who effortlessly maintains the numberless stars and galaxies in their myriad courses throughout the universe. What is weak, brief-lived, earth-crawling man to question his Creator?

But when Job humbled himself, and cast away all self-importance, God graciously went much further to set Job’s mind at perfect rest, and doubly compensated him for all his faithfully-borne suffering and shame. He totally vindicated and honored him before his self-righteous friends, and gave Job the joyful, forgiving privilege of being their mediator.

Restoration

And then He justified Job before his whole community, and made him twice as rich as he had been before. After what Job had bitterly learned of the fickle respect and fellowship of men (who fled when he needed them, and came back shamelessly seeking his favor when he was restored), and had gloriously learned of the companionship of God, the riches and honor would mean little to him, except as an even greater opportunity to resume his former course of goodness and guidance and charity to others, succoring the needy and defending the oppressed.

Some have felt that the restoration of the temporal riches and honor detracts from the spiritual force of the story, which is otherwise played out on a wholly spiritual plane. Such think incorrectly, again unwisely judging God’s ways. It was fitting and necessary — for the instruction of all Job’s associates, and all since — to complete the picture by the double restoration of all he had lost.

And it brings the closing picture fully into harmony with the antitype. Job, in well-deserved riches and honor — after passing triumphantly through all his trials for the inspirational and instructional benefit of the race — rejoiced to see his sons and his sons’ sons, in peace and prosperity.

So Christ, in eternal riches and honor, shall see his redeemed Seed: a holy, perfected “generation of the race” —

“HE SHALL SEE OF THE TRAVAIL OF HIS SOUL, AND BE SATISFIED.”

“How unsearchable are God’s judgments and His ways past finding out!”

(GVG)

Jacob the wrestler

After twenty years of servitude in Syria, Jacob prepared his family and fled from his father-in-law, Laban, back to the land of promise:

“And Jacob went on his way, and the angels of God met him. And when Jacob saw them, he said, This is God’s host: and he called the name of that place ‘Mahanaim’ ” (Gen 32:1,2).

“Mahanaim” signifies “camps” or “armies” and in this case alludes to the two “camps”: that of Jacob’s family, and that of God. Elisha’s revelation to his servant, at a later date, stresses the same lesson: Though the opposing forces appeared overpowering, yet if the young man’s eyes were truly opened they would behold on his side the armies of heaven:

“Fear not: for they that be with us are more than they that be with them” (2Ki 6:16).

Likewise, David wrote of the angel of the Lord, who “encampeth (‘hanah’ — the same root as ‘Mahanaim’) round about them that fear Him, and delivereth them” (Psa 34:7).

And Jesus, facing his sternest trial, could testify to the unseen presence of twelve legions of angels (Mat 26:53), hovering over and protecting himself and his flock.

For Jacob, this vision of angels, coming as it did at a time of danger and fear, should have sustained and comforted him. And it did — up to a point. But how far such a vision can intrude upon and override the “reality” of one’s experience, it is difficult to say. We read that, immediately after seeing the company of angels, Jacob nevertheless took steps to “insure” his success. He sent messengers ahead to appeal to his estranged brother Esau, whom he feared (Gen 32:3-5).

True to his lifelong tendencies of character, Jacob plotted and “wrestled” with circumstances, all to his “best advantage” as he saw it. He demonstrated an interesting combination of trust in God and trust in his own wits — interesting particularly in this: that Jacob is so much like the rest of us. This story is an invitation to us, to see ourselves in Jacob.

***

“And the messengers returned to Jacob, saying, We came to thy brother Esau, and also he cometh to meet thee, and four hundred men with him. Then Jacob was greatly afraid and distressed: and he divided the people that was with him, and the flocks, and herds, and the camels, into two bands; and said, If Esau come to the one company, and smite it, then the other company which is left shall escape” (vv 6-8).

Jacob had just seen the company of angels. Why did he fear?

If we can answer that question, then we can answer the more relevant question — Why do WE fear?… why? when Scriptures are filled with messages of surpassing comfort and mercy… messages that speak to us… “Fear not, little flock”!!

Although he was afraid for his safety and that of his family, Jacob never really doubted the presence and the interest of God. And so he prayed to the God of his fathers, reminding Him of His promises, reminding Him of His past mercies: “Oh God… I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies, and of all the truth, which Thou has shewed unto Thy servant… (yet) Deliver me, I pray Thee, from the hand of my brother” (vv 9-12).

His prayer was a retrospect of his life: “With my staff I passed over Jordan, and now I am become two bands.” In remembering past evidence of God’s guidance and comfort in his life, he strengthened his confidence in a present continuance of such guidance. Despite his fear of Esau, Jacob showed faith in God (v 11) and in His Word (v 12). Distress made his prayer fervent, as nothing else could. No insipid, practiced, routine prayer was this; it was real and meaningful!

But still, Jacob continued to make material provisions for his safety: he arranged bribes, and sent emissaries ahead with them (vv 13-21), all so careful and calculated — as he always had been. Was this necessary? Should he have bothered with… should he have even thought of such matters if he truly trusted in God?

There are no easy answers to such questions. In the warm security of our homes, nestled in easy chairs, with food aplenty, and the “world” at bay somewhere outside, the answer comes easily:

No, of course not. There was no need. But turn us out of our homes, strip from us our “security”, expose us to the dangers of the world in an immediate, life-threatening sense, and — if we are honest — we will admit that our perspectives would be drastically altered. So it was with Jacob. Let us, who “stand” so casually when all is calm, take heed lest we “fall” when the storms beat upon us.

“And he rose up that night, and took his two wives, and his two womenservants, and his eleven sons, and passed over the ford Jabbok. And he took them, and sent them over the brook, and sent over that he had” (vv 22,23).

Here is perhaps the best explanation for these confusing verses:

The whole company was first of all on the south side of the Jabbok, “exposed” to Esau and his men. Jacob returned all his family to the north side and relative safety, and then re-crossed the Jabbok, and remained on the south side alone, to face the “enemy.”

There he stayed, alone and watching through a dark night of fear, inner turmoil, self-doubts, and even (perhaps?) doubts about God. Time after time the question would rise in his mind. What will the morning bring? Can any of us, with even the slightest inclination toward a true self-examination, fail to be moved by a contemplation of that night? Can any of us, made as we are of flesh and blood, look upon such a scene and fail to recognize ourselves? “Behold, thou art the man!”

***

Then, suddenly, out of that night, a figure approached, shrouded in darkness. His heart leaped — was it Esau? What should he do? At once he was on his feet, advancing and grappling with the unrecognizable “enemy” (v 24). In the heat and fear of the night he sweated and wrestled, as though his life depended on his own strength. But through his desperation came the awakening realization that he would never prevail.

Then, at a touch the “enemy” disabled him totally: his leg was lame to the point of uselessness (v 25). Now there was nothing left to do but cling in abject helplessness to the mysterious figure that had bested him in the struggle. What power was this against which he had been wrestling? It could not be Esau! Could it be… God Himself? Still more desperately now, Jacob clung to the being who made as if to depart:

“I will not let thee go, except thou bless me” (v 26). No longer Jacob the wrestler, nor even Jacob the clever schemer, he was now Jacob the humble supplicant, begging the most meager crumb from the master’s table: “Please, bless me.”

“And he said unto him, What is thy name? And he said, Jacob. And he said, Thy name shall be called no more Jacob, but Israel: for as a prince hast thou power with God and with men, and hast prevailed.” (vv 27,28).

The “supplanter” (literally, the “one who takes by the heel”) is transformed into “the prince with God”. His “power with God” is achieved through humility and prayer, in inverse proportion to a trust in his own strength. In his “weakness” he prevailed and became “strong”- the full realization of his own emptiness and hopelessness bound him absolutely to the only true source of strength (2Co 12:7-10). And only then could he find the blessing!

***

Brethren, do we wrestle with God? How do we confront our “enemies”? Do we go through life dividing our time between praying and plotting? Do we ask for help and then scheme in unworthy ways to obtain our goals, giving the lie to all our worthier thoughts? Do we twist and turn and worry under every constraint to our own wills, never pausing to remind ourselves that God is in control of everything, and that what we “suffer” as well as what we “enjoy” contribute alike to His purpose?

It is so easy to forget the lesson of Shimei’s cursing of David, that God had sent the “enemy” — so who are we to ask “why”? (2Sa 16:10). Likewise, the reply of Jesus to Pilate: “Thou shouldst have no power at all against me, except it were given thee from above” (John 19:11). For us the problem is the same as Jacob’s: how to remember in our troubled hours what we take for granted in our quieter moments; that “All things work together for good to them that love God” and, “If God be for us, who can be against us?” Assuredly we shall all come to times when our theoretical belief in such an idea will be put to the test of reality.

***

This momentous event in Jacob’s life is the theme for inspired commentary in other Scripture passages:

“Who shall ascend into the hill of the Lord? Or who shall stand in His Holy place? He that hath clean hands, and a pure heart; who hath not lifted up his soul unto vanity, nor sworn deceitfully. He shall receive the blessing (Gen 32:26!) from the Lord, and righteousness from the God of his salvation. This is the generation of them that seek Him, that seek Thy face (‘Peniel’ — Gen 32:30,31!!), O (‘God of’ — as in mg) Jacob” (Psalm 24:3-6).

The experiences of Jacob the wrestler had deeply touched the heart of the psalmist David. So he learned, as must we, to see the “face of God” (Peniel!) in every experience, and especially in every crisis!

And in Hosea 12:3-6:

“He took his brother by the heel in the womb” –

Jacob’s birth epitomized his early life, a continual struggle for material advantage.

“By his strength he had power with God” –

Wherein was his strength? Certainly not in the arm of flesh!:

“He had power over the angel, and prevailed: he wept, and made supplication” –

Here was Jacob’s only source of strength — a recognition of his personal weakness.

“He found him in Beth-el” –

a reference to Jacob’s earlier vision of angels (Gen 28).

“And there he spake with us.”

And so the inspired prophet invites us, as we have been doing, to see ourselves in Jacob, and Jacob in ourselves. The experiences of this flesh-and-blood man have direct relevance to us. Do we fear and doubt? Do we vacillate between faith in God and scheming on our own account? So did he! But in his weakness he was drawn finally and completely to God. Let us have the humility and grace, and wisdom, to follow his path.

There is comfort in this thought, that Jacob never became perfect — that he never could bring himself to trust God absolutely, and yet God loved him. And so it may be with us. God has condescended to be known as the “God of Jacob” (the one who “wrestled”), not just the “God of Israel” (the “Prince with God”)!!

***

“And Jacob called the name of the place Peniel: for I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved. And as he passed over Penuel the sun rose upon him, and he halted upon his thigh” (Gen 32:30,31).

The “thorn in his flesh”, like Paul’s, was not removed. It remained with Jacob as proof and reminder of his encounter with God. And so we all “limp” through life, our failures and weaknesses witnessing eloquently to us of our need — our desperate need — to trust in God alone. We survey our lives, remembering the times when we, personally, failed … yet, in those failures found God.

As Jacob limped toward his meeting with Esau, the sun rose upon him! The doubts, the shadows, and the fears were gone with the night. He had seen “God” face to face, and through his weakness found a blessing. Now, when at last he saw Esau, he would still be seeing “God” (33:10). From now on, he would always God’s “face”, wherever he went.

***

Our Father, Help us to see Thy “face” in all our experiences.

Cause the light of Thy truth to shine into our hearts,

so that — abandoning our own wills and our own strength — we come at last to trust in Thee alone. In Christ we pray. Amen.

Jacob’s ladder

The ladder (or more properly, stairway) may signify the ages of time between Jacob’s day and Christ’s day. During these ages, the angels (God’s messengers and ministers: Heb 1:14; Psa 34:7) have been working with the saints and the world to achieve the Kingdom. This stairway joins heaven and earth. In the Kingdom Age, Jacob and saints will have “climbed” the stairway (or, to put it another way, Christ will have descended: Act 1:11), and Christ and his saints will have been united in Jerusalem.

The stairway also symbolizes Jacob’s seed, in generations to come, extending from Jacob himself all the way to the Messiah.

“Now the interval of time between the giving of the promise and the fulfilment of it was represented to Jacob by a ladder of extraordinary length, one end of which stood at Bethel, and the other end against the vault of heaven. Here were two points of contact, the land of Judah and heaven; and the connecting medium, the ladder, between them. This was a most expressive symbol, as will be perceived by considering the uses to which a ladder is applied. It is a contrivance to connect distant points, by which one at the lower end may reach a desired altitude. It is, then, a connecting medium between points of distance. Now if, instead of distant localities, distant epochs be substituted, the ages and generations which connect them will sustain a similar relation to the epochs as a ladder to the ground on which it rests, and the point of elevation against which it leans. The ladder, then, in Jacob’s vision was representative of his seed in their generations and appointed times. One end of it was in his loins; the other, in the Lord Jesus when he should sit upon his throne, reigning over the land upon which Jacob was asleep” (Elp 270).

John 1:51: “I tell you the truth, you shall see heaven open, and the angels of God ascending and descending on the Son of Man.” That is, “UPON the son of man”; ie, Christ IS the stairway, linking man to God, and vice versa.

“Alas, we make a ladder of our thoughts, where angels step — but sleep ourselves at the foot. Our high resolves look down upon our slumbering acts” (CAL, Xd 64:247).

Also, compare John 1:46: ” ‘Nazareth! Can anything good come from there?’ Nathanael asked. ‘Come and see,’ said Philip. When Jesus saw Nathanael approaching, he said of him, ‘Here is a true Israelite, in whom there is nothing false (or “no guile”).’ ”

Nathanael — like Jacob before him — unburdened his heart to God, threw off his guile, and repented of his past sins. Coming face to face with his Savior, and seeing heaven opened, he became a man drawn to God.

Angels ascending and descending on the “ladder”: Possibly the phrase “ascending and descending” is used in that order to show Jacob that the angels had been with him all along, even though their care and guidance at times was unperceived. They, of course, had ready access to God and their going and coming pointed out that fact.

Jacob’s life, a type of Israel

The great events of the life of Jacob serve as types of the national life of Israel in the last days. A few of the most extraordinary, with suggestions as to the spiritual significance of each:

  1. Jacob is specially chosen as God’s seed of promise, over him who is physically more impressive, and despite obvious shortcomings of character (Gen 25:23,27). THIS IS INDICATIVE OF ISRAEL’S SELECTION AS GOD’S SPECIAL PEOPLE, THOUGH THEY ARE NOT THE STRONGEST, MOST NUMEROUS, OR MOST RIGHTEOUS NATION.

  2. Incurring the anger of his less favored brother, Jacob must flee from the land of promise (Gen 27:43). IN THE SAME WAY HIS DESCENDANTS WERE FORCED BY SUCCESSIVE GENTILE NATIONS — ASSYRIA, BABYLON, AND ROME — TO WANDER INTO EXILE. (HARAN, WHERE JACOB DWELT, IS NEAR HALAH AND HABOR BY THE RIVER GOZAN, WHERE THE CAPTIVES OF ISRAEL WERE RESETTLED BY THE ASSYRIANS: 2Ki 17:6; 18:11.)

  3. In the midst of his flight, Jacob receives a vision of God’s angels watching over him in his exile, and a promise that He will bring him back into the Land (Gen 28:13,15). ALSO OF THE NATION OF ISRAEL IT MIGHT BE SAID: “BEHOLD, I THE LORD AM WITH THEE, AND WILL KEEP THEE IN ALL PLACES WHITHER THOU GOEST, AND WILL BRING THEE AGAIN INTO THIS LAND.” OR, AS THE PSALMIST PUTS IT: “THE LORD SHALL PRESERVE THY GOING OUT AND THY COMING IN” (cp Deu 28:6).

  4. In exile, Jacob’s band increases in numbers and wealth, bringing good fortune to his friends and consternation to his enemies, until the time that Laban’s displeasure toward him causes him to look again toward his homeland. THE DISPERSED OF ISRAEL SUFFER AT ALIEN HANDS AND YET ARE ENRICHED BY GOD, PREPARATORY TO THE TIME OF THEIR RETURN TO THE ANCESTRAL LAND.

  5. In his return to Canaan, Jacob wrestles with the angel, is humbled and bows down in humility, at last to be blessed and receive a new name (Gen 32). THE NATION OF ISRAEL WRESTLES WITH GOD IN THE PERSON OF JESUS CHRIST (IN HIS SECOND AS WELL AS HIS FIRST COMING), WILL BE HUMBLED (WEEPING WHEN SHE REALIZES THAT HER FATHERS CRUCIFIED THE MESSIAH), AND WILL BE BLESSED AT LAST AS THE “FIRST DOMINION” OF GOD’S KINGDOM, JOYFULLY TAKING UPON HERSELF A NEW NAME, THAT OF THE REJECTED SON OF GOD.

  6. Jacob returns to the Land to assume his birthright and receive unexpected friendship and solicitations of his brother Esau (Gen 33). THOSE OF ISRAEL WHO HAVE COME THROUGH THE “FIRE” AND ACCEPTED CHRIST AS THEIR KING RETURN FROM THE LANDS OF THEIR CAPTIVITY TO ASSIST THE LORD GOD IS RECLAIMING HIS RIGHTFUL INHERITANCE. ALL RESISTANCE FROM FORMER ENEMIES IS SWEPT AWAY, AND ISRAEL DWELLS IN PEACE, “THE THIRD WITH EGYPT AND ASSYRIA, A BLESSING IN THE MIDST OF THE LAND” (Isa 19:24,25).

Jdg, overview

Author: Samuel or another prophet (date of writing: c1050 BC or shortly thereafter).

Time: 1400-1100 BC.

Summary: After arriving in Canaan, many Israelites became disobedient to God, partly because of their failure to drive out the inhabitants of the land. The book of Judges shows how God raised up leaders to call them back to faithfulness and to continue the conquest of the land. It covers the period from the death of Joshua to the establishment of the monarchy under Saul. The book of Judges closes by setting the stage for the people’s desire for a human king.

Key verses: “Whenever the Lord raise up a judge for them, he was with the judge and saved them out of the hands of their enemies… But when the judge died, the people returned to ways even more corrupt than those of their fathers” (Jdg 2:18,19).

1. Introduction: Jdg 1:1 – 3:6
a) Israel’s failure to purge the land: Jdg 1:1- 2:5:
b) Political background (Jdg 1:1-36).
c) Religious background (Jdg 2:1-5).
d) God’s dealings with Israel’s rebellion, and their failure to subdue the nations of Canaan: Jdg 2:6 – 3:6
2. Oppression and deliverance: Jdg 3:7 – 16:31
a) Othniel: Jdg 3:7-11
b) Ehud: Jdg 3:12-30
c) Shamgar: Jdg 3:31
d) Deborah: Jdg 4:1-5:31
e) Gideon: Jdg 6:1-8:35
f) Abimelech: Jdg 9:1-57
g) Tola: Jdg 10:1-2
h) Jair: Jdg 10:3-5
i) Jephthah: Jdg 10:6-12:7
j) Ibzan: Jdg 12:8-10
k) Elon: Jdg 12:11-12
l) Abdon: Jdg 12:13-15
m) Samson: Jdg 13:1-16:31
3. Appendices: Religious and moral disorder: the lawlessness of the Judges period: Jdg 17:1 – 21:25
a) Corruption of doctrine: Jdg 17:1 – 18:31
b) Corruption of practice: Jdg 19:1 – 21:25